Skip to content
Original Candy House

Retro candy stocking stuffers

Christmas stockings hung over a fireplace, in an old photograph

A stocking full of the candy someone grew up with gets more of a reaction than another chocolate Santa. Every candy below is still made, so you can actually find it. The year is when it first came out.

Gum

  • Dubble Bubble (1928): the original pink bubble gum, in twist wrappers with a comic.
  • Bazooka gum (1947): a chunky pink piece with Bazooka Joe inside.
  • Hubba Bubba (1979): softer gum made so a popped bubble peels off your face more easily.
  • Big League Chew (1980): shredded gum in a pouch, made to look like chewing tobacco.
  • Bubble Tape (1988): six feet of gum rolled up in a case the size of a hockey puck. It fits a stocking perfectly.

Things on a stick

  • Sugar Daddy (1925): a slow-melting block of caramel that lasts a long time.
  • Tootsie Pop (1931): a lollipop with a Tootsie Roll in the middle.
  • Blow Pop (1973): a lollipop with bubble gum in the middle.
  • Ring Pop (1977): a hard candy jewel on a plastic ring.
  • Push Pop (1986): a long lollipop in a plastic tube with a cap.

Novelty candy

  • Pez (1927): add a character dispenser and it doubles as a small toy.
  • Fun Dip (1940s): flavored sugar with a candy stick for dipping.
  • Candy necklace (1958): pastel candy rings on elastic to wear and nibble.

Hard candy that lasts past Christmas

  • Jolly Rancher (1949): glassy, very fruity hard candy.
  • Atomic Fireball (1954): a big cinnamon jawbreaker for anyone who likes it hot.
  • Lemonhead (1962): sweet outside, sour layer, hard center.
  • Zotz (1968): hard candy with a fizzy center that foams when you bite in.
  • Everlasting Gobstopper (1976): layers that change color and flavor as it shrinks.

Chewy candy

  • Tootsie Roll (1907): the chewy chocolate classic.
  • Abba-Zaba (1922): taffy with a peanut butter center, in the checkerboard wrapper.
  • Bit-O-Honey (1924): honey taffy with bits of almond.
  • Chick-O-Stick (1950s): a flaky peanut butter stick rolled in toasted coconut.
  • Now and Later (1962): hard little taffy squares that soften as you chew.
  • Laffy Taffy (1970s): stretchy fruit taffy with a joke on every wrapper.

Regional bars they can't get at home

These are made by small companies and sold mostly near home, which makes them a fun surprise for someone who grew up there and moved away.

  • Goo Goo Cluster (1912): marshmallow, nougat, caramel and peanuts in milk chocolate, from Nashville.
  • Cherry Mash (1918): a cherry center covered in chopped peanuts and chocolate, from St. Joseph, Missouri.
  • Idaho Spud (1918): a potato-shaped marshmallow bar with chocolate and coconut, from Boise.
  • Valomilk (1931): a chocolate cup of runny marshmallow cream, from the Kansas City area.
  • Mallo Cup (after 1936): a chocolate cup of whipped coconut marshmallow cream, from Altoona, Pennsylvania.
  • Twin Bing (1960s): two cherry nougat centers covered in peanuts and chocolate, from Sioux City, Iowa.

Classic Christmas candy for the top of the stocking

A candy cane, a few Hershey's Kisses or a Terry's Chocolate Orange in the toe is a tradition of its own. Our old-fashioned Christmas candy guide has the history of each.

Tips

  • Pick candy from the decade they were a kid. The candy by decade pages list what was new each year.
  • Mix textures: one gum, one lollipop, one chewy and one hard candy.
  • Keep chocolate away from the fireplace. A stocking hung over a lit fire gets warm enough to melt it.
  • Ordering online? Order early in December, since regional bars and seasonal candy sell out.
What old-fashioned candy is good for a stocking?

Small, long-lasting candy works best: Sugar Daddy, Tootsie Pops, Atomic Fireballs, Bazooka gum, Pez with a dispenser and a candy necklace are all still made.

What candy did kids in the 1980s get in their stockings?

Candy that came out in the 1980s and is still made includes Big League Chew (1980), Push Pops (1986) and Bubble Tape (1988). Ring Pops (1977) and Hubba Bubba (1979) were around too.

Where can I find regional candy bars like Goo Goo Clusters or Cherry Mash?

They are sold mostly near where they are made, but candy shops that stock old-fashioned candy and the makers' own websites often carry them.

Questions and memories from readers

Remember Retro candy stocking stuffers, or have a question about it? Share it here. We add the best to this page.

Ask a question

We post answers here. Please leave out personal details.

Also on this site